This is the second time in about two weeks my family has ordered pizza under the new ownership of this Redlands staple. Their pizza is as good as ever. We always order two pizzas and half order of the cheese bread w/marinara sauce. They make a special pizza just for my son with Alfredo sauce and chicken since he is not able to eat marinara sauce due to dietary limitations. The staff is polite and courteous and willing to do what ever it takes to make your dining or takeout experience the most pleasurable they can. Please tell your friends and family to come and check out the new and improved jerseys pizza.

This place is very nostalgic for me and it is why I love coming here. My parents met here and I grew up eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is one of a kind. The amount of toppings and the amount of cheese is to die for! The vegetable ziti is very yummy and great quality veggies and basil. I also love the decorations they have and the 80s rock playing in the back completes my love for Jerseys pizza. Everyone needs to go here at some point!

Our mother is Italian, 1st generation in the US. She has always cooked and it's always been excellent. we have never gone out for Italian. she's now in her late 80's, and she is letting us bring her a couple of dinners a week. Friday we brought her a pepperoni pizza with mushrooms from Jersey's and a salad. She loved it!!! She has requested her pizza always come from here, and she said the salad was excellent! This is the highest praise from Mom. Well done!!

Jerseys is a no nonsense pizza shop. You are going to get thick crust, super cheesy, and a dense crust. The ingredients are fresh and the sauce is made on site. It's real good pizza. They will also make you a thin crust pizza if that's what you prefer. It's small, can be loud, and they have a small bar. Pizza is a little pricey, but what isn't nowadays? Give it try, it's better than most in the IE.

It has been over 10 years since we ate at Jersey's. We really enjoyed it. We came with a large party of 12 and they were very accommodating. The pizza was delish. I was worried because I saw some reviews about overcooked crust but ours were perfectly cooked! Will definitely be back.

4.5 STARS!!! This was my first time at this location and Wow! If you are looking for thick crust pizza made WELL, this is the PLACE! I am so impressed with the flavors of my Pesto + mushroom + green pepper pizza. It was DELICIOUS!!! Now keep in mind this place is pretty pricey. A SMALL pizza w/ 2 toppings + small soda cost me $20! (they also don't offer free refills on any drinks..even fountain soda cup -that's half ice- which I think is a bit ridiculous-hence the minus 0.5 star) But for the food itself, at least the pesto pizza, FIVE STARS!!!! (Note: if you're eating alone, the small pizza can give you about 2 meals because the slices are thick Vs the mini pizza which you'll likely finish on the spot. So if you want to take pizza leftovers home, consider the small+) The ambiance is very "moody, family bar" lol which sounds kinda strange but that's the best way I can describe it. Patrons of all ages were seated within the restaurant. There were also a lot of "regulars" who the workers could call by name, so that speaks volumes in and of itself. The workers themselves (though few) are very friendly! If you're starving and want your food within 5-10 mins, this may not be the spot for you. Because due to limited workers + everything being made on the spot- It takes quite a bit of time to get your food (which makes the no free refills even more unfortunate because likely you'd have finished the drink they gave you, before your pizza ever arrives) BUT if you're willing to wait, it is WORTH IT! Will definitely be returning!